The MLB The Show 25 Weekend Classic is one of the MLB The Show 25 Stubs most competitive modes in the game, where players build their dream squads to compete for rewards. Outfielders are crucial to any team’s success, providing elite defense, speed, and power. In this guide, we break down the best outfielders available in the Weekend Classic into tiers—S (elite), A (great), B (solid), and C (usable but flawed).

Whether you're looking for a five-tool superstar or a budget-friendly option, this tier list will help you optimize your outfield for maximum performance.

S-Tier: The Elite Game-Changers
These players are the cream of the crop—dominant in every aspect of the game. If you can afford them, they’re worth every stub.

1. Mike Trout (99 OVR – Angels)
Why He’s S-Tier: Trout remains the gold standard for outfielders in MLB The Show. With maxed-out contact, elite power, and great speed/defense, he’s the most complete player in the game.

Best For: Players who want a no-weakness outfielder who can bat .400 and rob home runs.

2. Ronald Acuña Jr. (99 OVR – Braves)
Why He’s S-Tier: Acuña combines 99 power, 99 speed, and a cannon arm. His swing is one of the smoothest in the game, making him a home run threat every at-bat.

Best For: Players who love aggressive baserunning and moonshot homers.

3. Ken Griffey Jr. (99 OVR – Retro Finest)
Why He’s S-Tier: Griffey’s sweet lefty swing and 125/125 power against righties make him an automatic pick. His defense is also elite, making him a complete package.

Best For: Nostalgic players who want the best lefty power bat in the game.

4. Aaron Judge (98 OVR – Yankees)
Why He’s S-Tier: Judge’s 125 power against lefties and righties is unmatched. His massive strike zone can be a slight downside, but if you square it up, the ball is gone.

Best For: Power hitters who want to hit 500-foot bombs.

A-Tier: High-End Performers
These players are just a step below the elites but still dominate in most situations. They’re more affordable while still being top-tier options.

1. Mookie Betts (97 OVR – Dodgers)
Why He’s A-Tier: Mookie’s versatility (he can also play 2B) and balanced stats make him a great choice. His swing is quick, and his defense is Gold Glove-caliber.

Best For: Players who value contact, speed, and defense over pure power.

2. Juan Soto (96 OVR – Padres)
Why He’s A-Tier: Soto has the best plate discipline in the game, with 125 vision and clutch. His power plays above his stats thanks to his smooth swing.

Best For: Players who love working counts and hitting lasers into the gaps.

3. Bryce Harper (97 OVR – Phillies)
Why He’s A-Tier: Harper’s lefty swing is one of the best in the game, and his power against righties is elite. His defense is solid but not spectacular.

Best For: Players who want a reliable lefty bat with big-time power.

4. Randy Arozarena (95 OVR – Rays)
Why He’s A-Tier: Arozarena’s speed and clutch hitting make him a menace on the basepaths. His power is sneaky good, and he can play all three outfield spots.

Best For: Players who love small-ball strategies and aggressive baserunning.

B-Tier: Solid Starters
These players are budget-friendly options who can hold their own but lack the elite traits of higher-tier guys.

1. Kyle Tucker (92 OVR – Astros)
Why He’s B-Tier: Tucker is a balanced hitter with good power and decent speed. He won’t carry your team but is a reliable mid-tier option.

Best For: Players looking for a lefty bat without spending big stubs.

2. Adolis García (91 OVR – Rangers)
Why He’s B-Tier: García has huge power and a cannon arm, but his contact and plate discipline can be inconsistent.

Best For: Players who want a power bat with great defense.

3. Luis Robert Jr. (93 OVR – White Sox)
Why He’s B-Tier: Robert has elite speed and defense, but his hitting can be streaky. He’s a great CF option if you prioritize defense.

Best For: Players who need a defensive anchor in center field.

4. Corbin Carroll (90 OVR – Diamondbacks)
Why He’s B-Tier: Carroll’s speed is game-changing, but his power is lacking. He’s a great leadoff hitter but won’t provide much pop.

Best For: Players who want a speedy contact hitter at the top of the lineup.

C-Tier: Niche or Budget Options
These players are usable but come with significant flaws. They’re best as temporary fill-ins until you can upgrade.

1. Starling Marte (88 OVR – Free Agent)
Why He’s C-Tier: Marte has decent speed and contact but lacks power and defensive range at this stage of his career.

Best For: Budget teams needing a righty bat.

2. Nick Castellanos (87 OVR – Phillies)
Why He’s C-Tier: Castellanos can hit for power but is a defensive liability. His slow speed hurts his value.

Best For: Players who need a cheap power bat in a corner outfield spot.

3. Taylor Ward (85 OVR – Angels)
Why He’s C-Tier: Ward is a decent all-around hitter but doesn’t excel in any one area.

Best For: Early-game teams looking for a placeholder outfielder.

Final Thoughts
Building the perfect outfield in MLB The Show 25’s Weekend Classic comes down to balancing power, speed, and defense. If you have the stubs, Trout, Acuña, and Griffey Jr. are the clear top choices. For budget-conscious players, Arozarena, Tucker, and MLB The Show for sale Robert Jr. provide excellent value.
https://www.mmoexp.com/Mlb-the-show-25/Stubs.html